Sign in to follow this  

Help me choose. . .

Recommended Posts

Hi Guys,


My unRAID array is nearly full and I want to expand storage (see below.)


Parity (4TB)
Parity 2 (4TB)
Disk 1 4 TB
Disk 2 2 TB
Disk 3 4 TB
Disk 4 4 TB
Disk 5 3 TB
Disk 6 2 TB
Disk 7 4 TB
Disk 8 4 TB
Disk 9 4 TB
Disk 10 4 TB
Disk 11 4 TB


I've come to a crossroads and need some advice. The two options I'm considering are:


1) Purchase 3 8TB drives:

  • Replace the 2 Parity Drives with 2 8TBs
  • Pull an old 2TB HDD and replace with 1 8TB
  • Re-purpose the old 4TB parity HDDs as replacements for the 3TB & 2TB HDDs to increase storage



Doesn't require too much interaction

Delays migrating to a larger, louder & ugly case



Expensive initial purchase

As needed, replacing 4TBs with 8TB HDDs will also be expensive

The disk rearranging will take some time; so there's some risk of "Murphy" rearing his ugly head.

I only have 13 drive bays; so as storage fills up, I'll be faced with this dilemma again at some point in the future

What to do with all the old 4TBs once they're retired


2) Purchase a Norco 4224 Case

  • Migrate the existing unRAID hardware to the new case
  • Continue to add 4TB HDDs until the unit is full.



Future 'Proof' in the sense I can upgrade to a bigger Mobo (ie dual core, Xeon CPUs, more RAM etc.)

24 Drive cages; instead of 13

Delays purchasing expensive 8TB HDDs; hopefully they will be more affordable once that becomes the next option.



Expensive initial purchase

PSU requirements - I have no idea how much or what kind of PSU I would need to power 24HDDs, and a bigger Mobo as a future purchase, etc. (this is the main reason I'm posting)

Loud & Looks hideous (I don't have a server closet, so it will be in a shelf in my room)

Excessive heat build up


I'm open to other options too, so any thoughts and help would be greatly appreciated!!





Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi -


If you have other reasons to want to get the extended dual CPU motherboard, then clearly a larger case is the way to go.  But are you planning to run lots of CPU or memory intensive applications?  There's overhead to running those large setups including more SATA controllers in addition to what you listed, personally I'd rather go the 8TB route unless you have specific plans that require the multi-CPU setup.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

I'd suggest getting the 3 8T. Replace parity and parity2. With other 8T, replace 2T+2T+3T=7T. So you'd have 1T free. You now have 2 empty slots. Buy 8T drives to fill those as needed. Use the 4T drives as backups or spares.


This should keep you a while. 


If any of your 4T are showing their age (near 5 years power-on hours)  or have SMART issues, I'd look to swap them out 2 for 1 with 8T.


Recommend the best buy easystore 8T externals, which are easy to open and extract WD Red inside. Cheap and good option. HGST 8Ts are more expensive, but are an even better quality option IMO. But with a big price difference, I'd probably be leaning towards the harvested Reds.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Thank you guys for your suggestions!! I'll probably do something similar to SSD's suggestion first, and then look to migrate the hardware to a Norco case sometime in 2018.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

Copyright © 2005-2017 Lime Technology, Inc. unRAID® is a registered trademark of Lime Technology, Inc.